MSC to Sell Back Its 49% in Moby After Action by Italy’s Antitrust Authority

By | 2025 Newsletter week 44 | No Comments

Gianluigi Aponte’s Mediterranean Shipping Company (MSC) has been forced to divest its 49% stake in Moby, the ferry company owned by the Onorato family operating between Italy and the islands of Corsica, Sardinia, and Sicily.

Italy’s Antitrust Authority announced on 24 October [in Italian] that it has accepted and made binding the commitments offered by MSC’s Shipping Agencies Services (SAS), Moby, and Grandi Navi Veloci (GNV), setting the terms of the divestment.

Under the settlement with the Competition Authority, SAS — a sub-holding of MSC — will transfer its 49% shareholding in Moby, free of charge, to Onorato Armatori, and will relinquish its pledge on the remaining 51%. The companies have also agreed to provide compensation to consumers who purchased tickets on Moby ferries.

It is also a setback for Moby, which has been ordered to repay the loan granted by Aponte’s group. The company announced a financial restructuring plan that includes the sale of assets. The proceeds will be used to repay the loan, while maintaining operations through charter-back agreements on some of the sold assets. If the proceeds are insufficient to cover the debt, the remaining amount will be transferred to independent third parties on terms safeguarding Moby’s financial stability.

The divestment is considered a win for the Grimaldi Group, which had challenged MSC’s investment in Moby on competition grounds.

Caronte&Tourist fined by the antitrust authority in Italy for abuse of dominant position on the Strait of Messina

By | 2022 Newletter week 16 | No Comments

The Italian antitrust authority sanctioned ferry company Caronte&Tourist with a fine valued EUR 3.7 million for abuse of dominant position on the maritime links in the Strait of Messina.

Last year,Italy’s Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato launched an investigation in order to ascertain whether the Messina-based company took an irregular advantage from a dominant position in the maritime transport of passengers with accompanying wheeled vehicles and commercial vehicles with driver.

Analysis carried out by the Authority revealed, in particular, that Caronte&Tourist applied prices which are significantly higher than those charged by other operators, moreover not parameterized with respect to the costs that would be expected in the performance of the service. Moreover, these prices appeared to be particularly discriminatory towards passengers with car travelling alone.

Grimaldi Asks Italian Authorities to Stop Paying Public Subsidies to Tirrenia CIN

By | 2019 Newsletter week 26 | No Comments

Italy’s financial newspaper MF-MilanoFinanza revealed that, earlier this month, Grimaldi Group sent a petition to the local Transport Minister, the Antitrust Authority and the Court of Audit, asking for an early termination of the subsidies (EUR 72 million per year) paid to CIN Tirrenia by the Italian State.

This subsidy supports lifeline maritime transportation with Sardinia, Sicily and Tremiti Islands.

Grimaldi stated that the public subsidies should be stopped due to breach of the public contract following the case sentenced by the Italian Competition Authority for alleged abuse of dominant position in the freight business in Sardinia and the alleged deferred payments under the CIN-Tirrenia purchase agreement.

Onorato Armatori later replied that Grimaldi’s petition is based on “false information”.